Gay Adoption-One Rabbi's Take On It

Rabbi Shmuley Boteach has written a very thoughtful article on gay and lesbian couples adopting children.  It really is giving this Orthodox Jew food for thought.
It is below in its entirety.  The original article is here.

The Morality of Gay Adoption

11/27/2010 22:18

Leaving orphans to drown without love is deeply immoral, but to stop others from rescuing them is an abomination.

  On December 14, Rosie O’Donnell and I will be conducting a public conversation in New Jersey about families and kids, the celebrity culture and the effects of fame, balancing work and career, and learning how to inspire our children.

It’s a subject Rosie is eminently qualified to address. This is, after all, the woman who walked away from one of television’s most successful programs and tens of millions dollars per year to raise her children. It will be followed by a fund-raiser for Turn Friday Night into Family Night – our national campaign to create weekly family dinners so that children are prioritized in the lives of their parents.

When I told a religious friend about being inspired by Rosie’s adoption of four children, he said to me: “How sad that these kids are never going to have a father.” Lost on him was the irony that without Rosie they wouldn’t have a mother either.

Now, Rosie has a media microphone and can fend for herself. But I think about all the other gay adoptive parents who are under assault as being ill-equipped to adopt. We’ve heard all the arguments: gay parents who adopt will make their children gay (offensive and stupid); every child deserves a mother and a father (I addressed this above); being gay is an abomination, to which I would respond that leaving a child to grow up in an orphanage where nobody wants him might be an even greater act of sacrilege.

TO MY fellow straight people I offer the following challenge. You have every right to oppose gay marriage; it’s a free country. We don’t suppress opinions.

But aren’t you under a moral obligation to adopt the children in their stead? Surely leaving kids to drown without love is deeply immoral. But to stop others from rescuing them is an abomination.

I am the father of nine children, thank God. I have at times discussed with my wife the possibility of adopting a child. Every child is a child of God. But my conversations have never gone past that, conversations.

I stand in awe of all those who actually do it. In my religion, there is no higher mitzva than raising a child without parents as your own. This is God’s child, and really He should have made provisions for him. But the Creator chooses, for reasons unknown to us, to hide behind the veil of Nature, and it is we humans who must fill in the seemingly empty spaces. Those who adopt are society’s and religion’s greatest heroes.

We all agree that every orphaned child is of infinite value. Some of us, however, pay mere lip service to the ideal. Others dress, feed and hug these children every day. They wake up in the middle of the night and nurse crying babies back to sleep.

They hug troubled teens and counsel them through life’s disappointments. They go to work every day to pay for college and weddings. Gay or straight, they make us all look small by comparison. And it would seem to me that it takes one heck of a lot of chutzpa to tell gay men or women not to adopt when we refuse to do so ourselves.

The same rule would apply to those who insist on ‘don’t ask, don’t tell.’ Oppose gays in the military.

It’s your right. You believe it compromises military morale and combat readiness. I get it.

But surely you’re going to sign up yourself, right? You’re not just going to deny a gay man or woman the right to fight terrorists who want to blow up innocent children and then spend your nights as a couch potato watching football. Surely you’re not going to prevent gays from protecting democracy and then run off to find a new 3D HD TV. Someone’s got to sacrifice for this country. And if you want to prevent gays from doing so, you have to grab a rifle and dodge the bullets yourself.

A FEW years ago on my radio show I interviewed two gay men who were in court fighting the government of Florida – my home state, where gay adoption is prohibited – to adopt a five-year-old African-American child who was mentally handicapped.

They had been picking the boy up from an orphanage every Sunday for about a year. One of the men said, “Nobody wants him. But we want him.”

I choked up. The show went to dead air. I could not speak or respond. “Nobody wants him. But we want him.” Here was a child whose skin color, for some, was all wrong and whose intelligence did not always match up. But to these two men the boy was perfect.

I believe their love for him was also perfect, and I believe that God loves these men for their dedication to this child, irrespective of how we view the morality of their relationship.

I am Orthodox; Judaism and the Bible have been the center of my life for all my 44 years. But if religion has not taught me to respect all men and women who adopt an unloved orphan and to be inspired by their example, then it has failed to bring out my humanity or change my heart.

That some would prefer that unwanted children remain in orphanages rather than in warm and welcoming homes is a sad commentary on the selfappointed morality police of our time.


Anonymous said…
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Batya said…
He's just too into celebrity for me to consider a posek.
Remember that halachikly things are different for goyim and Jews.
Anonymous said…
Yes, you DO know me... I'm surprised you can't recognize me from my picture, albeit with a slightly covered face. I am פײװעל יוסף, though I also answer to Adam :-)
Lady-Light said…
Yid: I don't believe I blew that one.
You don't look like yourself (in real life you look a lot me, anyway)!
Must have been having a...senior moment (gottenyu!)

Thanks for continuing to read my blog. See ya in shul!
Anonymous said…
The Torah is clear about the abomination of homosexuality. We cannot allow misplaced compassion to cloud the reality of this fact. To allow homosexual adoption is to bend the minds (morally) of these children, further exacerbating an aveira. R. Boteach has become corrupted by Hollywood and big money, chas v'shalom; he already crossed the line by touching women because it plays better on TV. He is not a posek.
Lady-Light said…
Batya: He is a celebrity, but he does quite a lot of good with his program "Shalom in the Home." He does reach people, and teaces them how to love and respect each other in family relationships. I don't consider him a posek, but what he says here gives one food for thought: it's the choice between letting a child stay in an orphanage or live with a loving family of his/her own.
And, although one can say that some halacha truly is different for Jews and goyim, the bottom line is that G-d created all human beings, and one of the tenets of Judaism is "ve-ahavta le-re'acha kamocha." I interpret that to mean that mitzvot bein adam le-chavero are important for all people, Jew and non-Jew alike.

Anon: Actually, I have read in several places that some Rabbanim have paskened that male homosexuality is the abomination proscribed in the Torah, not female.
That being said, it is true that in general, homosexuality is definitely NOT the natural order of things.
By definition, children raised in a homosexual home would grow up believing that their parents' lifestyle must be "ok," or they wouldn't be living that way.

On the other hand, to condemn a child to a loveless, lonely life is an abomination as well.

"Touching women" (as you put it) by shaking a woman's hand, or even giving one of his clients a 'hug' does not cross a line, in my book. The kavanah is what is important: the intent. And the intent here is to show care about someone and to end the sessions on a warm, positive note.
There is NO sexual intent in Rav Boteach's behavior.
Anonymous said…
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

Popular posts from this blog

A Beautiful Name for a Beautiful Soul

The Great Debate: Is it Itsy Bitsy, or Inky Dinky, of Spider Fame?

The End. Is there a Beginning...?